Lyric Opera Presents COSI FAN TUTTE Review – Channeling Moliere Opera-style

Though it’s obviously suggesting a cart before the horse, this reviewer could not help – even in the first notes of the Cosi fan tutte overture— to think of the fun-loving mischievous Mozart many of us came to know best through the film Amadeus. The melodies don’t just fill up the opera house, they do so prancing. It is the epitome of signature light-hearted excellencefrom Mozart that the film imagines drove Antonio Salieri to distraction. And from the gitgo, it’s also a frolic melody that evokes the vision of Wolfgang’s rolls above, under and around the couch with the lady he so clearly enjoyed, similarly driving his scold of a father to rage.

 That Mozart DID like the ladies—and the program notes also suggesting librettist Lorenzo Da Ponte did too—has quite a bit of relevance to Cosi fan tutte (translated as Thus do all women and subtitled The School for Lovers).  Here, a somewhat cynical man about town, Don Alfonso (Alessandro Corbelli) is trying to spare his young idealistic friends Ferrando (Andrew Stenson) and Guglielmo (Joshua Hopkins) from their naïve belief that their respected betrotheds Dorabella (Marianne Crebassa) and Fiordiligi (Ana María Martínez) are as pure and constant as can be. You imagine that even in the top balcony they can feel, if not see, Don Alfonso rolling his eyes at his two friends’ puppy love. He wagers them that he can prove that these women- as all women – are inconstant and just human.

The story unfolds to let Don Alfonso make his point, with the kind of disguised identities and plot twists you expect in many a Shakespeare comedy. And, much as you can find no shortage of misogynistic lines in Shakespeare’s works, you would do well to also remember that one of Shakespeare’s best-known odes to his beloved even includes a fondness for her bad breath.   Fickle though Dorabella and Fiordiligi are proven to be, Don Alfonso, with the aid of the maid and woman of the world Despina (Elena Tsallagova), makes the greater point that it behooves all to accept humans as humans.

Lyric Opera accentuates the farce

In this production especially, it’s not only Shakespeare that is evoked but rather the romp of a Molière farce. This is funny stuff! Some program notes cite critics claiming that Da Ponte’s libretto seems out of sync with Mozart’s melodies. This reviewer thinks it better to note that there are few other operas that seem to reliably summon the audience to so many guffaws and belly laughs, largely thanks to the many bon mots set to melody. At times, you end up not knowing quite whether you are more delighted by the mellifluous voices of tenor Stenson and baritone Hopkins, or their ability to look like cartoon character cut-outs striking comical he-man poses and such.

This production (Original Director: John Cox; Revival Director: Bruno Ravella) is set in a pre-World War I Monte Carlo like seaside resort. The set oozes light and carefree, tickling most when it adds simple touches like pastel balloons moving like dancers to lighten up a moment (Set and Costume Design: Robert Perdziola).

Of course Cosi fan tutte is most about the music—solos, duets, and more— and especially the ensemble sync with the orchestra under the baton of James Gaffigan. Your ears will thrill not only to hear the soprano and mezzo-soprano coloratura but also to hear the flutes trill in an accompanying duet.   From this writer’s perspective soprano Ana María Martínez doesn’t bring the same comic timing chops to bear as her fellow female leads, but more than makes up for it when she shines in her many solo arias. Crebassa’s mezzo voice and person sparkle so much you feel that there is an intense spotlight on her at all times. Better, when these two female voices meld in a duet you are more than ready to forget the story line so as to better savor the aural splendor. This is singing and song that would enthrall in a concert hall without benefit of story, costumes, etc.—and so much of it often does.

Some tips and cautions are in order. At times this 3 ½ hour opera experience feels especially long because there is only one intermission after a 90-minute first act. Larks might especially seek out a March matinee. And, for those who are thrown by such, do know ahead of time that especially in the beginning, there is lots of recitative set-ups accompanied by harpsichord.   The main tip is to join in on the superlative pre-performance lecture. Unlike others that seem to do little more than recite the plot synopsis you can read in the program book, this lecturer gives a compact précis peppered with commentary from the performers on how they interpret their role and the story, as well as sampling musical highlights one should listen for.



Note: This is now added to the Picture this Post round up of BEST PLAYS IN CHICAGO, where it will remain until the end of the run. Click here to read – Top Picks for Theater in Chicago NOW – Chicago Plays PICTURE THIS POST Loves.


Six performances through March 16.


Lyric Opera House
20 North Wacker




For tickets visit the Lyric Opera website or call 312-827-5600.

All photos by Cory Weaver and Andrew Cioffi


Note: An excerpt of this review appears in Theatre in Chicago

Don Alfonso (Alessandro Corbelli) takes his two young friends (Andrew Stenson and Joshua Hopkin) under his wing to prove that women are fickle and inconstant Photo: Corey Weaver
The two disguised men (Joshua Hopkins and Andrew Stenson) woo the two sisters (Marianne Crebassa and Ana María Martínez) Photo: Cory Weaver
Soprano Elena Tsallagova totally charms as Despina, the scheming maid and accomplice to Don Alfonso, Photo: Cory Weaver
Mezzo-soprano Marianne Crebassa's beautiful voice and stage presence make her a charismatic standout every time she is on Photo: Cory Weaver
Joshua Hopkins and Andrew Stenson make both the libretto's comedy and their beautiful arias, duets and more come to life Photo: Cory Weaver
Ana María Martínez is the more thoughtful sister Fiordiligi who eventually comes around to cheating on her fiancee, as Don Alfonso bet she would Photo: Cory Weaver
Co-Publishers Amy Munice and Peter Kachergis

About the Author:  Amy Munice

Amy Munice is Co-Publisher and Editor of Picture This Post.  As Editor, she is the keeper of the Picture This Writers' Guidelines. 

Read more about her and other Picture this Post writers on the Picture this Post Masthead.  

Click here to read more Picture this Post articles by Amy Munice

And, click here for  Travel Stories by Amy Munice with Photography by Peter Kachergis

Amy Munice

About the Author:

Amy Munice is Editor-in-Chief and Co-Publisher of Picture This Post. She covers books, dance, film, theater, music, museums and travel. Prior to founding Picture This Post, Amy was a freelance writer and global PR specialist for decades—writing and ghostwriting thousands of articles and promotional communications on a wide range of technical and not-so-technical topics.

Amy hopes the magazine’s click-a-picture-to-read-a-vivid-account format will nourish those ever hunting for under-discovered cultural treasures. She especially loves writing articles about travel finds, showcasing works by cultural warriors of a progressive bent, and shining a light on bold, creative strokes by fledgling artists in all genres.


Share this:

Make a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *