Underscore Theatre Company Presents THE BALLAD OF LEFTY & CRABBE Review – Lots of Bits

The Ballad of Lefty & Crabbe doesn’t just begin—it explodes. Two Vaudevillian comics —Lefty (Kyle Ryan) and Crabbe (Shea Pender) — are cranky when they find each other in what they each think is his own dressing room.  Then, in the blink of the speeding metronome that paces this musical, they are both on stage in the first of many Who’s On First?  moments.

Underscore Theatre Company THE BALLAD OF LEFTY & CRABBE
(left to right) (front, l to r) Katy Campbell, Shea Pender and Natalie Rae
Underscore Theatre Company THE BALLAD OF LEFTY & CRABBE
(left to right) Katy Campbell, Brian Huther, Stephanie Boyd, Kyle Ryan, Shea Pender, Reagan Pender, Ben Auxier and Elisabeth Del Toro

For the next two hours Groucho’s ghost keeps the punch line drum rolls coming as these two Vaudevillians become fast friends and newbies in Tinsel Town.  Meanwhile, the rest of this uber-talented cast – only eight in number but feeling more like a theatrical Army Division — heaps on the song, dance and action, switching characters faster than the speed of an action video game.

This story by cast members Ben Auxier and Brian Huther (also with Seth Macchi on Book) is full of bits, but nary a bit player.  Lefty & Crabbe might be the headliners but it’s their fellow cast members that are the anti-void, from their quirky manager who sleeps in a trunk (Brian Huther), to their physical trainer (Reagan Pender,  in on of many roles allowing him to flex his accent put-on muscles), to the Hollywood mogul lush who hires them (Stephanie Boyd), and more.  This writer imagines that to portray the swarmy fast-talking Hollywood agent E.G. Swellington, actor Mike Ott did a séance to summon W.S. Gilbert’s ghost to teach him how make the scripts bon mots do their ever silvery speed from his tongue.

For those of us lucky enough (read: old enough) to have sat at the knee of elders who came of age in Vaudevillian times, know that you too will likely adore the way playwrights/composers Auxier and Huther have somehow bypassed the slow demise of verbal dexterity that was once commonplace for any high school graduate.  It’s not only language-based shticks-- though that’s the main juice--but also a lot of physical slapstick too.  (Spoiler Alert!) For this writer, watching the cast take a bouncing train ride together is in itself a treasured moment for the memory banks.

Underscore Theatre Company THE BALLAD OF LEFTY & CRABBE
(center, l to r) Kyle Ryan and Shea Pender with (back, l to r) Stephanie Boyd, Katy Campbell, Brian Huther, Ben Auxier, Elisabeth Del Toro and Reagan Pender
Underscore Theatre Company THE BALLAD OF LEFTY & CRABBE
(center) Elisabeth Del Toro
Underscore Theatre Company THE BALLAD OF LEFTY & CRABBE
(left to right) Reagan Pender, Natalie Rae, Brian Huther, Katy Campbell and Kyle Ryan

Underscore Theatre Picks Another Jewel-in-the-Rough Musical Masterpiece

The music is catchy, in this writer’s view, if not especially transporting.  But it is the glue that allows this cast to “put on a show”, to paraphrase a recurring lyric. Though we get breathers here and there from croons so ably delivered (especially Natalie Rae as speakeasy singer Evelyn Rose and Elisabeth Del Toro as Lolo Carmichael) this reviewer craved a chaser of a few more tension breaks a la Harpo just silently smiling and giving non-verbal horn toots.

This is a Day at the Races style marathon of fun.  The cast seems to be having a ball—and you feel it.  If you just can’t get enough of those oldie comedy flicks born more of Vaudeville stages than silver screen, you are well-advised to change your schedule to catch this show.  And if you just want a couple of hours of fun escapism, this is a good pick too.


Note: This is now added to the Picture this Post round up of BEST PLAYS IN CHICAGO, where it will remain until the end of the run. Click here to read – Top Picks for Theater in Chicago NOW – Chicago Plays PICTURE THIS POST Loves.

Watch this video showing the TOP PICK PLAYS of 2019


Book and Lyrics by Brian Huther, Ben Auxier & Seth Macchi
Music by Ben Auxier and Brian Huther
Additional Music and Arrangements by Ryan McCall
Directed by Rusty Sneary
Music Direction by Ryan McCall
Choreography by Jenna Schoppe


Ben Auxier, Stephanie Boyd, Katy Campbell, Elisabeth Del Toro, Brian Huther, Mike Ott, Reagan Pender, Shea Pender, Natalie Rae and Kyle Ryan. Swings: Sophia Foldvari and Nate Hall.


Thru July 14
Friday and Saturday at 7:30 pm
Sundays at 4 pm
Mondays at 7:30 pm.


The Understudy Theater
4609 N. Clark St.



For tickets visit the Underscore Theatre website.

Photos by Evan Hanover.

Note: Picture This Post reviews are excerpted by Theatre in Chicago

Amy Munice

About the Author:

Amy Munice is Editor-in-Chief and Co-Publisher of Picture This Post. She covers books, dance, film, theater, music, museums and travel. Prior to founding Picture This Post, Amy was a freelance writer and global PR specialist for decades—writing and ghostwriting thousands of articles and promotional communications on a wide range of technical and not-so-technical topics.

Amy hopes the magazine’s click-a-picture-to-read-a-vivid-account format will nourish those ever hunting for under-discovered cultural treasures. She especially loves writing articles about travel finds, showcasing works by cultural warriors of a progressive bent, and shining a light on bold, creative strokes by fledgling artists in all genres.


Share this:

Make a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *